The Staff at PInow.com, a worldwide directory of investigators, compiled a top 10 list of the most interesting, sexy, and cool fictional detectives and PIs of all time.
You watch them on TV, you read about them in your favourite novels and watch them on the old silver screen, but how do your favourite PIs and detectives fare against the best of the best? Read on:
 |
10) Scooby-Doo and Those Pesky Kids (Fred “Freddie” Jones, Daphne Blake, Velma Dinkley, and Norville “Shaggy” Rogers). First an animated show and then a cultural phenomenon, this is where most of us first learned about private investigation. The members of “Mystery, Inc.,” are definitely unlicensed, but few professionals make driving around in an old van and uncovering old crooks dressed as ghosts look so cool. |
 |
9) Inspector Jules Maigret. The French do it, too. Georges Simeon’s police inspector was streetwise, kind, and unassuming as he solved Paris’s crimes and worked for the Parisian police. Created by writer Georges Simenon, Maigret appeared in seventy-five novels and twenty-eight short stories from 1931 to 1972, after which he was the star in numerous television shows. In many ways, the loveable inspector embodied all our favourite stereotypes about detectives – he smoked pipes, relied as much on intuition as on technique, and often stopped by watering holes for a drink. |
 |
 Hercule Poirot. Agatha Christie’s Belgian detective appeared in more than 50 short stories and 30 novels. The very neat detective with the huge moustache and small frame was one of the eccentrics of the private eye world, worrying about his shoes and his stomach with all the fussiness of an old maid. For all that (and maybe because of it) we rather like the old chap. |
 |
7) The Shadow. The character created by Walter B. Gibson is pulp hero, appearing in movies, books, comic books, and radio shows. We love pulp heroes, and this detective was the star of the pulp fiction world through the 1930s and 1940s. With a mysterious past, the Shadow lurks out of sight, solving crimes. We love the fact that The Shadow was a hard-working detective – he was featured in more than 325 books, solving hundreds of mysteries and crimes. Now that’s work ethic. |
 |
6) Dashiell Hammett’s Sam Spade hails from the macho era of hard-boiled detectives. No great sensitivity here, just fedoras and plot twists and turns aplenty. Whether you are reading Hammett’s short stories or watching or reading The Maltese Falcon, it’s hard not to admire Sam. We always did like the strong, silent types. |
 |
5) Remington Steele. The title character of the TV show that made Pierce Brosnan a household name was not even a TV character at first. In the show, it is Laura Holt who is a private detective. When she finds that few clients are willing to work with a female detective, she invents an imaginary superior named Remington Steele. The fake name is eventually adopted by Brosnan’s character. |
 |
4) Magnum, P.I. In this 80s television show, Thomas Magnum, played by Tom Selleck, was a private investigator working in Hawaii. Thomas Magnum preferred being called a “private investigator” over “detective” or “private eye”. With a tropical background and that famous, cool moustache, what’s not to love about Magnum, P.I.? |
 |
3) Jessica Fletcher from Murder, She Wrote was the ultimate in nosey, loveable armchair detectives. A very prolific writer, Fletcher lived in quiet Cabot Cove, Maine, which somehow turned out to be a crime center that made NYC look tame by comparison. Who knew? Jessica was the one that taught all would-be authors that every book tour for mystery authors ended in a mystery or a murder. We also adore Angela Lansbury – she made being a busybody positively glamorous (well, almost – this was the 1980s). |
 |
2) Addison and Hayes. Where would we be without those wacky 80s PI shows? In the classic Moonlighting, Blue Moon Detective Agency has two partners, Madolyn ‘Maddie’ Hayes (Cybill Shepherd) and David Addison (Bruce Willis), who solve crimes each week while bantering and flirting (while pretending not to flirt, of course). This is where all those professional but sexually tense TV relationships started – way before Mulder and Scully. |
 |
1) Sherlock Holmes, the fictional character that author Sir Arthur Conan Doyle grew to hate, was the first one to make a deerstalker cap and magnifying glass something besides hopelessly geeky. Maybe his mastermind and cool, scientific reasoning made him more like a Star Trek Captain than a sexy James Bond, but at least Holmes was having fun snorting coke and playing his violin at 221B Baker Street. |
There are many great fictional investigators and detectives that have adorned the big screens and television, and who have come alive through books and comics. We surely have overlooked some of your favourites.
Please comment on whom you would include on your top 10 and we will follow-up with a reader’s choice article.
About PInow.com
PInow.com (http://www.pinow.com/) is a Worldwide Directory of Private Investigators that enables law firms, corporations and the general public to find investigators anywhere in the United States and worldwide.
i vote for inspector gadget, columbo and nancy drew
Comment by trizzle — January 11, 2007 @ 11:25 am
My all time favorite is the Dark Knight detective “Batman”.
Comment by Charles — January 12, 2007 @ 11:37 am
Columbo, Philip Marlowe and the Coolest of all - Jim Rockford
Comment by Ray P. — January 12, 2007 @ 11:42 am
Mickey Spillane-the tough guy who carried a .45 and had a pack of Luckies with him on every case along with meeting some dangerous femme fatals
Comment by RD Furman — January 12, 2007 @ 1:23 pm
The list can not be complete without the PI’s PI, Jim Rockford.
Comment by Snake Roberts — January 12, 2007 @ 2:43 pm
There are so many good ones however Remington Steele, Sherlock Holmes, Sam Spade and of course Inspector Gadget and Rockford rate at the top of my list.
Comment by S. Lee — January 12, 2007 @ 5:40 pm
Inspector Morse (cudos to anyone who knows his first name), fictional Detective Inspector from the UK’s Thames Valley Police. As a former Thames Valley Officer (who on occassions got to crowd control for Morse filmings) I am obliged to see he gets an honorable mention.
Comment by Drew Witham — January 12, 2007 @ 7:47 pm
way to pass up inspector clusoe guys
Comment by captain ninjawoofer — January 12, 2007 @ 11:28 pm
What about Mannix, who caught a beat down and hardly ever collected his fee
Comment by Joseph Macchio — January 15, 2007 @ 6:59 am
My vote goes to Jim Rockford, the Rockford Files. I always got a kick out his trailer and his portable business card machine. He did PI work the old way, not like today!
Comment by R.J. Slepski — January 15, 2007 @ 11:00 am
Clouseau and Maigret aren’t PI’s, they are COPS. And you didn’t mention Phillip Marlowe, C. Auguste Dupin, Mike Hammer, Spenser, Adrian Monk, Jim Rockford, Rick and AJ Simon or my favorie Tracer Bullet (from Calvin and Hobbes)!
Comment by Billy Dykes — January 16, 2007 @ 12:11 pm
My favorite is not only Remington Steele, but
the woman who created him, Laura Holt.
Comment by Isabel Bartol — January 16, 2007 @ 10:29 pm
[...] The films are expected to maintain the dark spirit of the Chandler books and will still be set in 1940s Los Angeles, with Marlowe continuing to be a hard-drinking, wise-cracking investigator. Tags: investigation, investigator, private investigator, clive owen, philip marlowe, raymond chandler [...]
Pingback by Investigation News - Clive Owen Is Set To Play Private Eye Marlowe - PInow.com Investigator Directory — February 4, 2007 @ 11:09 am
[...] Fiction has permanently identified the private detective with the deerstalker cap and magnifying glass (Sherlock Holmes), the trench coat (Sam Spade) and the Ferrari (Magnum, P.I.). Fictional sleuths tackle seemingly unsolvable puzzles, often while exchanging witty banter with a partner, like Dave and Maddie in “Moonlighting.” [...]
Pingback by Investigation News - Local private eyes offer peek inside their profession - PInow.com Investigator Directory — February 6, 2007 @ 10:52 am
[...] OK, so the private eye isn’t Sam Spade. And it’s not the real Maltese Falcon, the statue made famous as the signature prop in the 1941 movie starring Humphrey Bogart. But the mystery is almost as intriguing. [...]
Pingback by Investigation News - Plaster Maltese Falcon takes a fly - PInow.com Investigator Directory — February 19, 2007 @ 1:21 pm
[...] Private investigator John March has come to life again in Ridgefield author Peter Spiegelman’s third book in the private eye genre, “Red Cat.” [...]
Pingback by Investigation News - Ridgefield author’s P.I. makes third appearance - PInow.com Investigator Directory — March 5, 2007 @ 3:20 pm
hbeup dahvk rcwnb iowylt cjrmoaft yzbw tcohfvngs
Comment by eksjylxar fzmbkox — April 8, 2007 @ 8:41 pm
Closseuo was an Inspector it was in his name, and we was always trying to solve a case. You forgot Dick Tracy and Ace Ventura Pet Detective. Aaaaaaaaaalllllrrrighty then.
Comment by Jason — November 3, 2007 @ 10:54 pm
mwxshkpy bydknuzt sgowhdck lxbjvhy mqgydic oyubt anmw
Comment by rjtn cvjdltk — November 22, 2007 @ 4:42 pm
[...] Investigation News - Scooby Doo, Magnum PI and the 8 other ‘best 11 Jan 2007. was the star of the pulp fiction world through the 1930s and 1940s… Pingback by Investigation News - Ridgefield author’s P.I. makes third. Entertainment · Feed for all posts filed under Entertainment.www.pinow.com/…/top-10-fictional-pi-detective-characters-of-all-time-3/ - Investigation News - Scooby Doo, Magnum PI and the 8 other ‘best [...]
Pingback by Grill restaurant - Grill menu - Bonefish grill menu restaurant — August 13, 2010 @ 6:30 pm